Aunt adopts nephew at birth because her sister couldn't care for him, sister asks for custody of him 8 years later: 'I can’t imagine giving him up. He is my son in every way that counts.'

Author image for Emmy Pratt
Emmy Pratt • Senior Editor
Sep 10, 2025 8:00 PM EDT

Putting a child up for adoption should not be taken lightly. It is not something that you can ever take back, and if you're unsure about the choice, you need to give it more thought. There are some situations where adoption seems to be the only real option. If an expecting mother cannot take care of herself in any meaningful way and requires the care of another adult to function, she should not be a parent. But there are a lot of situations that are borderline. Perhaps a young couple is committed to each other, but they're struggling to make ends meet, let alone support another person. They certainly have some options if they want to be parents. They could get better jobs, move to a cheaper area, or move closer to family to offset some of the costs of child rearing. They have every right to put their child up for adoption if they genuinely think there won't be a way for them to support a baby properly, but all is not lost if they want to be parents and are willing to make a lot of sacrifices to do so. 

Advertisement

  • The birth mom in this story asked her sister to take her baby in because she didn't feel fit, and her sister was aching for a child. Her sister has been his mom for eight wonderful years, but now that the birth mom is in a more stable place, she wants him back. That's not how it works. 

  • A woman holding a baby
    via Silverius Trandafir

    Image is representative only and does not depict the actual subjects of the story.

  • Am I wrong for refusing to give my sister back the child I’ve raised as my own?

    I (35F) have been married to my husband (38M) for almost 10 years. Our marriage always felt incomplete because we weren't blessed with a child, no matter how much we tried.
    via u/JollyForYou
  • A few years ago, my sister got pregnant unexpectedly and the father was never in the picture. She came to us asking if we could shoulder all the hospital bills and take the baby in. My husband and I agreed, we paid for everything, and we even registered the child under our last name. From that day on, we raised him as our own.
    via u/JollyForYou
  • A man and woman holding a baby
    via Silverius Trandafir

    Image is representative only and does not depict the actual subjects of the story.

  • We loved him wholeheartedly treat him as our firstborn. We always told him that biologically, his mom is my sister, but he never cared he only recognized us as his parents.
    via u/JollyForYou
  • After many years of trying, my husband and I were eventually blessed with a biological child of our own. We're beyond grateful, but now my sister has started making comments that she wants to take her child back since we "already have our own."
    via u/JollyForYou
  • A woman with tattoos and red lipstick posing
    via Joseph Etchingham

    Image is representative only and does not depict the actual subjects of the story.

  • This feels so unfair. I never kept her from visiting she's always been welcome in our home to see him but she never showed much gratitude. she now feels entitled to just take him away, as if the years we've spent raising him don't matter.
    via u/JollyForYou
  • I can't imagine giving him up. He is my son in every way that counts. AITA if I fight to keep him with us and refuse to hand him over to my sister? PS: My firstborn son is 8 years old and my daughter is 4 years old.
    via u/JollyForYou
  • EDIT INFO: Yes, the child is legally under our name. We have a signed agreement from her, and on the birth certificate we are listed as the legal parents. I believe that's enough proof against her claim.
    via u/JollyForYou
  • Mera 1506 INFO. Did you legally adopt him? Tell sister a child is not a possession. She should be doing what's best for him. And best for him is not uprooting his entire life.
    via u/Mera1506
  • Jolly For You OP Yes, we adopted him legally. She even signed the papers because she don't want to raise the child on her own.
    via u/JollyForYou
  • Certain-Thought531 "Dear sister, while I am verry happy that your life has gotten better to the point you can consider raising children, I would like to remind you that children are living people, not some commodities that can be given or taken whenever one feels like it, even pets don't deserve to be treated in such a way, even less children.
    via u/Certain-Thought531
  • Please understand that while you will always be welcome in his life as his loving aunt, ***** is now my and my partner's child, and will remain as such for both his well being and stability"
    via u/Certain-Thought531
  • JipC1963 Absolutely NTA! Your Son may be cognizant of who his biological egg-donor is but YOU are his Mother in every sense and purpose and have been since his birth. I hugely doubt that any authority or medical/psychological professional would ever "sign off" on your Sister regaining parental rights or custody unless there was any evidence of ab_e. Keep fighting for your child and children. He's not a toy to be shared or taken back.
    via u/JipC1963
  • Jolly For You OP Thank you! We've been his parents in every way that counts. and we'll keep fighting to protect him.
    via u/JollyForYou
  • Cardabella He's legally yours child as much as if you'd birthed him yourself. the are no take backsies with adoption. If she can't love him as a nephew and respect you as the parent she may need to have less contact.
    via u/Cardabella
  • No-Technician-722 THIS You don't need her poisoning his mind. Kids are vulnerable. I would be around whenever she has access.
    via u/No-Technician-722
  • Difficult Ad_502 As an adoptive parent I whole heartily agree with this. My daughter knows her birth mother, but we are her parents.
    via u/Difficult_Ad_502
  • p3canj0y363 NTA. How unfair to your son, to uproot his entire life? I would feel legal advice here. Is your sister stable, emotionally and financially? What an awful, selfish thing to do to.
    via u/p3canj0y363
  • Jolly For You OP yes, she was struggling emotionally and financially so that's why we took all the bills and everything.
    via u/JollyForYou
  • SundaeWithBae She's not thinking about the kid at all. She's thinking about herself, her image, her control. If she cared about his well-being, she'd never try to rip him away from the only parents he's ever known.
    via u/SundaeWithBae
  • WitchesAreMyBitches The question is, what does your son think about her being his bio mum and so on? As at 8, he's old enough to decide for himself if asked by a court of law. Oh and NTA!!
    via u/WitchesAreMyBitches
  • Illustrious_Bobcat Not really, at 8 years old judges don't put much care into what the kid wants yet, too young to make a logical decision. Some judges don't even care what 16 year olds want. And that's when guardians actually share legal rights to the child. Legally, the child is OP's son. Her sister has no legal way to get the child back unless OP and her husband both agree and they obviously don't want to. She doesn't even have visitation rights, any more than any other random Aunt would for
    via u/Illustrious_Bobcat
  • Even if the child wanted to be with her instead, OP and her husband would have to agree to another adoption and the sister would have to be approved for said adoption. OP didn't say if her sister was married or not, but if not, a judge might not even approve it because the child would be leaving the home they grew up in with two stable parents and moving into a home with his single biological mother who never mothered him.
    via u/Illustrious_Bobcat
  • They don't like to adopt to single parents if a couple is available, unfortunately. It does happen, but most states won't even let a parent relinquish their rights by choice without a step parent by marriage to legally adopt the kid. And that's with one loving, stable parent in the mix.
    via u/Illustrious_Bobcat

Want More? Follow Us and Add Us as a Preferred Source on Google.

Tags

adopt nephews family drama child adoption mother siblings wife husband aunt dad family sibling sister mom son Father custody Reddit
Scroll Down For The Next Article